11/24/ · Create a detailed outline To help illustrate one of the more difficult steps of prewriting and drafting, devising a decisive outline, a sample outline of a book critique for Kaffir Boy by Mark Mathabane is detailed below. The outline is itemized, providing samples of what each section should include along with writing tips and blogger.comted Reading Time: 8 mins Book Critique blogger.com Loading 7/4/ · A book critique example provided in the article below will help you get the idea of how a book critique is written. Read on to find the fundamentals of writing. 1 () 1 () Estimated Reading Time: 9 mins
17 Book Review Examples to Help You Write the Perfect Review | Reedsy Discovery
分享 取得連結 Facebook Twitter Pinterest 電子郵件 其他應用程式. Napier and Carl A. Whitaker, explores the intriguing and complex dynamics among family members and between the therapists and the clients in family therapy. This paper will discuss the general themes found throughout the book and provide personal reflections for each chapter. MAJOR SECTIONS The Question of Structure The main theme of the chapter is the issue regarding who should attend the family counseling session. However, the therapists insisted that all of the family members played a part in the seemingly individual problems, and stressed example of book critique importance of Don attending the session as well.
They told the family that Don was the person who was chosen by the entire family to stay at home, so the family did not have to face their issues. The reason for such a battle for structure was that the family was afraid of exposing their entire world, all the worries, anxieties, histories, and anger.
In this chapter, the authors provide an important concept that it is necessary for all family members to participate in family therapy because example of book critique their age or personality, example of book critique, they all play a part in the problematic situation. A Beginning When Don appeared for the first time, example of book critique, the therapists finally could begin their therapy for the Brice.
When David talked about their family issues, he focused on Claudia and it seemed that she was the source of all problems. However, the therapists encouraged Don and Laura to express how they felt about their family disputes and pain, and it appeared that the children were more honest and direct than their parents. During this session, the therapists skillfully shifted the attention from Claudia to the relationship between David and Carolyne Napier and Whitaker, They made known that the fundamental issue was actually deeply rooted in the parents, and Claudia was the one who simply cooperated with her parents to keep their relationship triangle working in an established pattern.
Although the members of this triangle seemed to be tired of endless arguments, they could not help but kept such a pattern going to maximize their conflicts to the point that they needed therapy, example of book critique.
The other issue is that it is common for Asian people to disregard statements from children because they consider children too young to understand things, and children have to show respect toward the authority of their parents and elders. Next, the authors briefly introduce psychoanalysis and point out fallacious concepts of it.
Therefore, when people seek therapy, they need more than their own awareness and insight Napier and Whitaker, From reading this chapter, I could easily feel the stress, fear, and helplessness that Claudia has experienced.
She was the family scapegoat who carried all responsibilities for her family problems. If she continued to undergo personal therapy against her own will, she might actually end up in a psychiatry ward, and the real issue, the marital relationship between her parents, might never be appropriately identified, discussed, and improved.
Next, example of book critique, this chapter helps me understand the limitation of traditional psychoanalysis and the biased views it provides. That is why family therapy has become more and more important. The Concept of the System This chapter explains the concept of the system and family therapy.
Researchers in the s began to discovered that schizophrenic patients were frequently in a situation of double bind, example of book critique, which means they were trapped in two contradictory example of book critique mostly from verbal and non-verbal cues from their mother, example of book critique, and the parents of most schizophrenic patients had prolonged and serious marital problems Napier and Whitaker, In the latter part of this chapter, the authors state that some psychoanalysis-oriented psychiatrists depreciated the notion of counseling the entire family, probably because this has threatened the status of medically controlled psychotherapy Napier and Whitaker, In my country Taiwan, medicine is still the major, frequently the only, example of book critique, treatment for curing all mental problems, and many counselors are still stuggling to get recognition from the medical community that non-medical treatments can also help.
There are more and more psychiatrists opening their own clinics, but I have not heard of any counselor or therapist having her or his own practice, not to mention family therapists. It is still a long way to go for local counselors and therapists here. Initiative In this chapter, the authors explain through their experience with the Brice that it is important for the family to know that they have to take initiative and be willing to work hard, struggle, take actions, example of book critique, and attempt in order to have a successful example of book critique. This certainly is not an easy task, and family members would often fall back to the pattern of blaming one another.
It is very couragous for the Brice to bring their conflicts and attacks at home to the therapy session. This is necessary, but at the same time challenging for anyone. Whitaker has told Claudia that confusion is the beginning of creativity Napier example of book critique Whitaker,and confusion was necessary if the Brice wanted to have a new prospect. This was a learning process for the Brice that helped them really be in the situation.
The Basic Conflict Family is a small society with its own structure, social order, rules, leadership, language, lifestyle, and thoughts. Each family has its own unique family dance, example of book critique, and only its members know what is going on within all the steps of their dance Napier and Whitaker, In this chapter, the authors introduce common family patterns, and stress the importance of co-therapy. They example of book critique therapy a symbolic experience for parental console, and the relationship of co-therapy the basic tool for example of book critique Napier and Whitaker, My sister and I learned to play piano because my mother did not have such an opportunity to learn it herself when she was young, example of book critique she expected highly toward our academic achievement, especially mine, because her parents had expected the same for her when she was still a student.
I remember that she used to talked about how she and her siblings got punished if they did not have good grades, and she would did the same verbally or physically if we did not have good grades or disobeyed her rules. My mother konwingly or unknowingly brought her issues with her parents, mostly her father, to us. According to Carolyne, her mother had a bad temper and was highly picky, and nobody in the family dared to offend her Napier and Whitaker, The authors once again demonstrate how family of origin affects example of book critique person and her or his own family later in life.
Since her parents, especially her mother, were the only ones who modeled the parental thoughts and behaviors, Carolyne naturally took such an attitude toward Claudia in addition to make her daughter act as an communication agent between she and her husband David, meanwhile example of book critique herself depressed. Continued from the previous section, my mother made us learn things she could not learn before, and reacted angrily when we did not follow her rules to have good academic performance or when we did things that she considered improper.
I used to hate this kind of treatment, but now I realize that she did not do it in purpose; it was a learned behavior. This chapter helps me understand that my mother did not feel pleasure when she scolded us, and whenever she did so, she would somehow recall those example of book critique memories between she and her parents mostly her father. Maybe it was partly because that her mother seldom had any say about disciplining children, and it made my mother sense that to act like her father was to have parental authority and power.
Toward Marriage Transference is the main theme of this chapter. The therapists gradually made Carolyne realize that she saw her angry husband as her mother when she was young, and they repeated over and over again the scenario of one person being extremely angry and the other weeping, example of book critique. When they discover that the issue is not as simple as they originally imagined, they begin to have transference, feel panic, react with anger or anxiety, and become more and more disappointed and depressed.
A Partial Resolution It is common that family members who constitute the source of family problems feel embarrassed and reluctant to go deeper into the core of their problems.
Because David and Carolyne did not communicate directly with each other for a long time, it was always through issues with Claudia that they communicate with each other. In fact, the entire family was afraid to discuss problems of the parents, and they worked together not to deal with such a controversial issue Napier and Whitaker, I have a feeling that people are frequently afraid of changes, even if their current situation does not satisfy them.
They try many ways to cope with their problems, formulate a pattern, and closely follow the pattern to obtain a sense of security. Change is good, but it is also risky, especially when people have to expose themselves to make such a change. Therefore, keeping the status quo will be the easiest, not necessarily the most effective, way to cope with the reality, example of book critique.
I am currently making a career shift from something else to counseling. I do not need to expose myself for this change, but it still took me a long period time of consideration to actually make such a move, and sometimes I still wonder if it is worthy. It is through prayer and encouragement from people who care about and help me that I keep going.
We surely cannot go through life changes completely alone, example of book critique. We need determination, help, sometimes therapy, and faith.
Releasing The authors show us once again the positive effect to bring family arguments into therapy sessions. Both the therapists and the family can understand more about what really causes all of the conflicts and learn from the repeated pattern in a neutral setting. Through practice, Carolyne and Claudia established a better communication mode with each other, and after several sessions, the therapists suggested that the Brice not coming to the session temporarily. Although the family members had mixed feelings about this, the authors indicate that their willingness to solve problems was their most precious resource Napier and Whitaker, It is the responsibility of therapists to help their clients express their own thoughts and feelings, and model for them the proper way of reaction and interaction.
However, therapists should be aware of the temptation of directly telling their clients what to do in order to solve their problems, because it is when the clients truly want to change, the change will then occur. Next, I sense that Carolyne depended on the therapy because she appeared anxious when she heard that the therapy was going to stop temporarily.
The underlying problem has not been solved yet. The Underlying Crisis According to the authors, creating a scapegoat is not the only solution for a family to deal with their issues.
In this chapter, the authors offer another example of a problematic marriage, and explain that extra marital affair is actually the result of the conspiracy between the husband and the wife. When a couple feel trapped in their own marriage, they feel disappointed because they are not able to get what they have desired from each other by transference. Therefore, they agree that one of them seek an outsider to stimulate their deadened relationship Napier and Whitaker, Although many problematic marriages end in divorce, divorce itself does not necessary terminate the pain.
I have always been thinking that people seek extra marital affairs because they do not get what they have hoped from their spouse, but I did not take the implication of incest into account until I have read this chapter. Because family of origin play an influential part on how a person behave and interact in a marriage, it is easy for people to bring transference into their own marriage and treat their spouse as their own parent.
In order to get away from such contradiction, having an affair provides a solution to keep them from emotional incest. Return After the temporary termination of the therapy, the Brice returned again and Don has become the new scapegoat this time.
David and Carolyne could not agree on a seemingly trivial issue, so they used Don to fight against each other Don also played his part, example of book critique. Once again, this couple was afraid of direct conflicts between each other, example of book critique, and if they continued this pattern of indirect communication, one of the children would always be the scapegoat Napier and Whitaker, It is so easy for the family to fall back into their old pattern of the conflict cycle, and this indicates the hesitation of all family members toward really making a difference.
I would feel somehow frustrated when the Brice came back if I were the therapist. It is also challenging for therapists to help any family get closer and closer to the core of marital problems without actually telling them what to do.
It takes time for therapists to establish a positive relationship with their clients. After that, the clients are able to truly listen to and accept any points of view from their therapist s. Hate It was true, from previous chapters, that Don considered himself as capable as an adult.
Later in the session, Mr. When the parents do not act like real parents, it causes confusion and misconception among their children, and it is not surprising that a role reversal occurs. It is shocking to read the physical conflict between Mr. Whitaker and Don because it is not ethical for therapists to physically fight with their clients. If this happened in more recent years, the Brice would have sued Mr.
Whitaker for unethical conduct, example of book critique. However, it was a time when the ethical standard has not become as strict as those in present days, and this fight was a result of circumstances and Mr.
Maybe such a fight was necessary for this particular family because the parents were deeply bothered by their own issues, and they did not model for their children the appropriate parent-child interaction, either. The Therapeutic Moment It takes the willingness of both the family and the therapist s to work things out in the process of family therapy. However, the family would unknowingly drag the therapist s into their own family system, and the therapist s would project their own family system upon the family being treated Napier and Whitaker,
Part 1: Summary Critique
, time: 14:34How to Write a Book Critique Like a Professional
11/24/ · Create a detailed outline To help illustrate one of the more difficult steps of prewriting and drafting, devising a decisive outline, a sample outline of a book critique for Kaffir Boy by Mark Mathabane is detailed below. The outline is itemized, providing samples of what each section should include along with writing tips and blogger.comted Reading Time: 8 mins 7/4/ · A book critique example provided in the article below will help you get the idea of how a book critique is written. Read on to find the fundamentals of writing. 1 () 1 () Estimated Reading Time: 9 mins If you decide to self-publish, I recommend having your book copyedited and proofread to ensure that your book is error-free prior to publication. Sample Critique #2 nonfiction: memoir
No comments:
Post a Comment